First day in a seminar today and as a group we read and then discussed Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield. The text is a short story only a few pages long told in the Third Person Omniscient Limited Narrative.
Now I'll get this out of the way because at first glance it's as difficult to read as it is to say. Presumably if you're reading this you'll understand the difference between First, Second and Third Person Narrative which means it's the latter two words that might be a little bamboozling. Omniscient according to thefreedictionary.com* means 'Having total knowledge; knowing everything', In the context of Miss Brill this just means that because we know what Miss Brill is thinking, the narrator has access to the knowledge, thoughts and feelings of the main character, while being told in third person. The Narrator knows everything. Later on there is a very abrupt change to limited, we no longer are told what Miss Brill is thinking, as she runs away from the Scene. This works to a startling effect but we'll cover that in greater depth further down.
Some of the Key themes are dealt with very specifically through the narrative style, principally the theme of illusion. The inclusive nature of Third Person Omniscient seems to be at odds with the separation she seems to feel and while we discuss in depth all the other characters, we in turn learn very little about Miss Brill. We do not find out her age, no great description upon her appearance - besides the fur. We don't entirely know where she is or what she does besides vague hints. This allows us to build a picture of both Miss Brill and the rest of the cast, purely based on our own connotations drawn from her opinions. It allows us to build an image of Miss Brill through her judgement of others; the lack of interest in the elderly couple who are sat next to her, as 'They did not speak.' and 'This was disappointing'. We are shown her motivations for being there and the enjoyment she takes out of people watching. We begin to identify with the character and to relate to her and we build a connection, an empathy, that at times might be pitiful or and sympathetic and at other times uncomfortable and frustrating. As we are shown around Miss Brill's mind we enjoy an opinionated impression of a whole theatre of characters, from lovers through to the drunk dog. Each one in turn highlighting an aspect of Miss Brill. The second couple going 'on the whole time about how she ought to wear her spectacles' and the discomfort she takes from the arguing woman, who she 'had wanted to shake . . .' highlights Miss Brill's own discomfort with the woman not appreciating her partner trying to make an effort, even after 'He'd suggested everything'. This begins to show us in to Miss Brill's loneliness.
The sudden change to First Person Limited then serves another purpose of highlighting Miss Brill's disassociation with reality. We no longer have access to her thoughts, all the actions in the last two paragraphs, narrate in third person limited; skipping her weekly treat, how 'quickly' she 'unclasped the necklet' and the final comment, 'she thought she heard something crying', references herself and shows us her refusal to acknowledge her own feelings. In limiting our sight in to Miss Brills mind in this way, Katherine succeeds in isolating our protagonist and encourages us to empathise with the characters loneliness.
Loneliness is a prominent theme throughout from the title; 'Miss' rather than Mrs, as you might expect from a woman of the age we might expect our Heroine to be, and Brill an 'insignificant' flatfish. The title is very significant in itself, it's catchy and cheerful, even the connotations of the word Brill in modern day society means something else, a very happy and excitable anachronism. There is a sense of irony coming through in this, although, convincingly others have made arguments to Miss Brill being much younger than I initially interpreted the character to be.
Miss Brill appears to be surrounded by couples through out the text; 'the old couple', 'An Englishman and his Wife', 'Two young girls and Two young soldiers', 'Two peasant women' . . . the list goes on. Miss Brill even draws relationships between characters that are separate; 'an ermine toque and a gentleman met just in front of her.' By surrounding herself in this way and by 'sitting in other people's lives' Miss Brill both distances herself from her surroundings and the audience while including the audience in her surroundings, isolating herself from all other parties. The only item that has any part in Miss Brill's life is the fur, the 'little Rogue!' whom she personifies and finds companionship with. The sensuality in this is ripe, the 'tingling in her hands and arms', a very sensual tactile description, that is reinforced with the dismissal of any possibility of affection, 'but that came from the walking,' and then the moments doubt, 'she supposed'. This brilliant little piece of description gives you a momentary glimpse in to the heart of this lonely, unloved woman. A woman of her suggested standing in a post World War One Europe would have unlikely had any sexual contact, this might have been quite a moment for such a lonely woman. The description the 'little Rogue', the adventurer and hero, the rugged and righteous, honourable but rough around the edges; our Indiana Jones, Han Solo, Robin Hood. The sexy and sensual man that might have been lost in the war, or perhaps was never had in the first place.
All of this allows us the picture of a lonely old lady, who has devised a fantasy world in order to live out her own idealistic adventures.
*I know it's disgraceful but I'm still waiting on my academic dictionary, thesaurus and literary glossary to arrive; so stick with me for a few days.
Engless Lessons
Thursday, 19 September 2013
Why blog?
I want to.
For many people, myself especially, learning becomes much easier once I have a voice, or a channel to communicate through. A way to express an opinion and to collate my notes, the blog is an ideal format. It will be literary and, for myself, beneficial; but it is by no means education, containing personal criticisms rather than an informed critique. I may discuss, content, context, linguistic analysis and Theory. I may discuss Author's and etymology, possibly genre and writing styles. I might even be tempted to touch upon the best wine to accompany a novel or poem (I find Poe is best with a rich Merlot and Carol Anne Duffy is best with a suicide capsule, but we're each allowed our own opinions). I will not be writing page after page after page and I will keep it as concise as possible without missing out huge chunks. And the content will be based around what I am reading at the time (judging by my course, that's a Lot!).* So you can expect sporadic and posts and detailed analysis in the same day. Most importantly though you'll find on here a fresh opinion and I'll find my notes all in one place.
*I feel as though the full stop is unnecessary here; but, English Grammar being as Vague as a Students late paper excuse, I generally have no clue.
*I feel as though the full stop is unnecessary here; but, English Grammar being as Vague as a Students late paper excuse, I generally have no clue.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)